• 0 Posts
  • 8 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: July 29th, 2023

help-circle

  • On “mutual ownership”. I’m not convinced that anything, whose agency has been removed through confinement, can be said to have equal weight in the decision to be owned, and thus be claimed “mutual”.

    You give evidence of our like behavior with other animals, and claim that my position MUST operate from the belief of our “difference and superiority”.

    Consider the inverse: Humans are not distinct and not superior. Therefor, all animal behavior is acceptable human behavior, for we are not but animals.

    Its not exactly the society most would want to live in. People can and do use animal nature as means to justify horrible behavior. “Its a dog eat dog world, the villain proclaims”, as if the only surprise is that their victim would have expected it any other way. Mantises devour the male after copulation. Why then do you demand I not do the same?! Pointing to the way things are in nature as a means to find justification for human behavior doesn’t seem to lead to a useful foundation for ethics; maybe it even to to its dissolution.

    So yes, I think we’re different. I think that in many ways our difference comes from our responsibility of stewardship. Because we do have knowledge, agency and control to the degree that we can destroy or restore environments.


  • ActionHank@sopuli.xyztoMemes@lemmy.mlThis is the way
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    19
    arrow-down
    10
    ·
    7 months ago

    Picking up wild animals which would much prefer to be left alone, so you can get your picture taken, is not loving them. Keeping animals in cages so you can have something on your shelf to look at, is not loving them. Most animal ownership is possession for the possessive, masquerading as caring.



  • ActionHank@sopuli.xyztoMemes@lemmy.ml¿¿Que??
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    1 year ago

    lol yeah I guess it depends on the length of the sentence and the context. Context is usually pretty clear for questions, and maybe exclamations are typically short enough that the ‘!’ is already visible anyways. Definitely wasn’t considering periods and commas in that list.